MOTIF

The rock in the surf — to stand unmoved under the blows

§ IImage

The headland (ἄκρα) against which the waves break without ceasing (διηνεκῶς); it stands firm (ἕστηκε), and around it the seething waters (τὰ φλεγμήναντα) are "lulled to rest" (κοιμίζεται). An image of the imperturbable soul under the blows of fortune: not to repel the blow by force, but to stand so that the storm itself subsides at one's foot. The waves — external events, others' faults, misfortunes — come on endlessly; the rock is neither moved nor harmed, and moreover it calms the waters around it: the steadfast soul does not add to the turmoil but stills it.

The image holds two thoughts: (1) the external does not harm the steadfast (DOGMAno-harm-to-virtuous) — the waves break, the rock is whole; (2) the state called for is imperturbability (TERMapatheia), freedom from TERMλύπη and fear. Kin to the "inner citadel" (inner-retreat).

§ IISource

04-49 — the image in pure form, opening the passage and setting the stance for the dogma that follows (to remain ἄλυπος under what strikes). The cognate series of steadfastness / the inner stronghold:

  • Med. 8.48 — the mind free from passions is a citadel (ἀκρόπολις): there is no more secure refuge to which to retreat;
  • Med. 4.3 — the "retreat" into oneself as the most untroubled refuge (see inner-retreat);
  • the contrast: to be "crushed by the present" (θραυόμενος, 04-49) — what the rock never is.

§ IIIUsage

In 04-49 the rock opens the practice of steadfastness and prepares the dogma "not a misfortune, but to bear it nobly is good fortune." It serves the discipline of assent / desire: imperturbability. Unlike the river of time (flux) and the ripe olive (gracious departure), here the stress falls on unmoving firmness — to stand, rather than to flow or to fall. Connections: DOGMAno-harm-to-virtuous (the waves do not harm the rock), inner-retreat (the inner stronghold).

MOTIF

The rock in the surf — to stand unmoved under the blows

Appears in2
Related3
Sections3

§ IImage

The headland (ἄκρα) against which the waves break without ceasing (διηνεκῶς); it stands firm (ἕστηκε), and around it the seething waters (τὰ φλεγμήναντα) are "lulled to rest" (κοιμίζεται). An image of the imperturbable soul under the blows of fortune: not to repel the blow by force, but to stand so that the storm itself subsides at one's foot. The waves — external events, others' faults, misfortunes — come on endlessly; the rock is neither moved nor harmed, and moreover it calms the waters around it: the steadfast soul does not add to the turmoil but stills it.

The image holds two thoughts: (1) the external does not harm the steadfast (DOGMAno-harm-to-virtuous) — the waves break, the rock is whole; (2) the state called for is imperturbability (TERMapatheia), freedom from TERMλύπη and fear. Kin to the "inner citadel" (inner-retreat).

§ IISource

04-49 — the image in pure form, opening the passage and setting the stance for the dogma that follows (to remain ἄλυπος under what strikes). The cognate series of steadfastness / the inner stronghold:

  • Med. 8.48 — the mind free from passions is a citadel (ἀκρόπολις): there is no more secure refuge to which to retreat;
  • Med. 4.3 — the "retreat" into oneself as the most untroubled refuge (see inner-retreat);
  • the contrast: to be "crushed by the present" (θραυόμενος, 04-49) — what the rock never is.

§ IIIUsage

In 04-49 the rock opens the practice of steadfastness and prepares the dogma "not a misfortune, but to bear it nobly is good fortune." It serves the discipline of assent / desire: imperturbability. Unlike the river of time (flux) and the ripe olive (gracious departure), here the stress falls on unmoving firmness — to stand, rather than to flow or to fall. Connections: DOGMAno-harm-to-virtuous (the waves do not harm the rock), inner-retreat (the inner stronghold).

Related3
Appears in2
4.49Be like the promontory against which the waves continually break, but it stands firm and tames the fury of the water around it. Unhappy am I because this has h…7.43No joining others in their wailing, no violent emotion. (Long)
CopyPassage