DOGMA

No harm can come to the virtuous

§ IFormulation

The sage — or, more broadly, the one who has understood where the genuine good lies — cannot be harmed from outside. Since the only real TERMevil is vice, and vice is one's own assent to a bad judgment, no external force can make a person vicious against his will. The external can wound the body, take away property, deprive one of the people one loves — but it cannot touch the TERMruling part unless the ruling part itself yields. The Stoic sage is therefore "unharmable" (ἀβλαβής) — not because he is shielded, but because harm is localised only where he is his own master.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF III 567–579 (on the invulnerability of the sage); classically: Plat. Apol. 30c–d, 41d ("the bad person cannot harm the better"); Sen. De const. sap. (a whole treatise on this thesis); Epict. Ench. 5; Disc. 1.18; 3.22.100. In Marcus: Med. 2.1; 2.11; 4.8; 4.49; 05-22 (what does no harm to the city does no harm to the citizen); 05-35; 06-21 (the truth harms no one; harm is persisting in one's own error); 07-14 (the external falls on the sentient parts; the ruling "I" takes no harm unless it judges what happened an evil — and not to judge is in its power); 07-16 (the ruling part suffers no harm unless it harms itself); 07-22 (the wrongdoer has not made your ἡγεμονικόν worse — hence no harm); 07-53 (acting according to one's constitution — no harm to suspect); 07-64 (pain is nothing shameful and makes the governing mind no worse); 8.41; 08-55 (κακία harms not another — only its own bearer, who is free to be rid of it); 08-56 (a neighbour's vice cannot become my evil — God arranged that my unhappiness may not depend on another); 09-04 (the reverse theorem: what harms a person is only what makes him worse — his own injustice; the unjust harms himself); 09-38 (if he erred, the evil is "there," with him; and perhaps he did not err); 09-42 (τί δὲ καὶ βέβλαψαι; no one of those at whom you boil has made your διάνοια worse).

§ IIINotes

In 02-01 the doctrine is carried through by a direct step: "no one can drag me into the shameful (αἰσχρόν)" — and therefore no one can harm me. The hidden premise: harm = vice = the shameful; everything else is no harm at all. Linked to dichotomy-of-control: harm is possible only in the sphere of what is up to us, and what is up to us is only our own assent. Therapeutically the doctrine removes the ground of anger: if my neighbour is unable to harm me, then indignation against him too is a category error, not a legitimate reaction.

DOGMA

No harm can come to the virtuous

Appears in22
Related4
Sections3

§ IFormulation

The sage — or, more broadly, the one who has understood where the genuine good lies — cannot be harmed from outside. Since the only real TERMevil is vice, and vice is one's own assent to a bad judgment, no external force can make a person vicious against his will. The external can wound the body, take away property, deprive one of the people one loves — but it cannot touch the TERMruling part unless the ruling part itself yields. The Stoic sage is therefore "unharmable" (ἀβλαβής) — not because he is shielded, but because harm is localised only where he is his own master.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF III 567–579 (on the invulnerability of the sage); classically: Plat. Apol. 30c–d, 41d ("the bad person cannot harm the better"); Sen. De const. sap. (a whole treatise on this thesis); Epict. Ench. 5; Disc. 1.18; 3.22.100. In Marcus: Med. 2.1; 2.11; 4.8; 4.49; 05-22 (what does no harm to the city does no harm to the citizen); 05-35; 06-21 (the truth harms no one; harm is persisting in one's own error); 07-14 (the external falls on the sentient parts; the ruling "I" takes no harm unless it judges what happened an evil — and not to judge is in its power); 07-16 (the ruling part suffers no harm unless it harms itself); 07-22 (the wrongdoer has not made your ἡγεμονικόν worse — hence no harm); 07-53 (acting according to one's constitution — no harm to suspect); 07-64 (pain is nothing shameful and makes the governing mind no worse); 8.41; 08-55 (κακία harms not another — only its own bearer, who is free to be rid of it); 08-56 (a neighbour's vice cannot become my evil — God arranged that my unhappiness may not depend on another); 09-04 (the reverse theorem: what harms a person is only what makes him worse — his own injustice; the unjust harms himself); 09-38 (if he erred, the evil is "there," with him; and perhaps he did not err); 09-42 (τί δὲ καὶ βέβλαψαι; no one of those at whom you boil has made your διάνοια worse).

§ IIINotes

In 02-01 the doctrine is carried through by a direct step: "no one can drag me into the shameful (αἰσχρόν)" — and therefore no one can harm me. The hidden premise: harm = vice = the shameful; everything else is no harm at all. Linked to dichotomy-of-control: harm is possible only in the sphere of what is up to us, and what is up to us is only our own assent. Therapeutically the doctrine removes the ground of anger: if my neighbour is unable to harm me, then indignation against him too is a category error, not a legitimate reaction.

Related4
Appears in22
2.1Begin the morning by saying to thyself, I shall meet with the busy-body, the ungrateful, arrogant, deceitful, envious, unsocial. All these things happen to them…2.11Since it is possible that thou mayest depart from life this very moment, regulate every act and thought accordingly. But to go away from among men, if there are…4.7Take away thy opinion, and then there is taken away the complaint, "I have been harmed." Take away the complaint, "I have been harmed," and the harm is taken aw…4.8That which does not make a man worse than he was, also does not make his life worse, nor does it harm him either from without or from within. (Long)4.26Hast thou seen those things? Look also at these. Do not disturb thyself. Make thyself all simplicity. Does any one do wrong? It is to himself that he does the w…4.37Thou wilt soon die, and thou art not yet simple, not free from perturbations, nor without suspicion of being hurt by external things, nor kindly disposed toward…4.39What is evil to thee does not subsist in the ruling principle of another; nor yet in any turning and mutation of thy corporeal covering. Where is it then? It is…4.49Be like the promontory against which the waves continually break, but it stands firm and tames the fury of the water around it. Unhappy am I because this has h…5.22That which does no harm to the state, does no harm to the citizen. In the case of every appearance of harm apply this rule: if the state is not harmed by this, …5.25Does another do me wrong? Let him look to it. He has his own disposition, his own activity. I now have what the universal nature wills me to have; and I do what…5.35If this is neither my own badness, nor an effect of my own badness, and the common weal is not injured, why am I troubled about it? And what is the harm to the …6.6The best way of avenging thyself is not to become like the wrong doer. (Long)6.21If any man is able to convince me and show me that I do not think or act right, I will gladly change; for I seek the truth by which no man was ever injured. But…7.14Let there fall externally what will on the parts which can feel the effects of this fall. For those parts which have felt will complain, if they choose. But I, …7.22It is peculiar to man to love even those who do wrong. And this happens, if when they do wrong it occurs to thee that they are kinsmen, and that they do wrong t…7.53Where any work can be done conformably to the reason which is common to gods and men, there we have nothing to fear; for where we are able to get profit by mean…7.64In every pain let this thought be present, that there is no dishonour in it, nor does it make the governing intelligence worse; for it does not damage the intel…8.55Generally, wickedness does no harm at all to the universe; and particularly, the wickedness of one man does no harm to another. It is only harmful to him who ha…8.56To my own free will the free will of my neighbour is just as indifferent as his poor breath and flesh. For though we are made especially for the sake of one ano…9.4He who does wrong does wrong against himself. He who acts unjustly acts unjustly to himself, because he makes himself bad. (Long)9.38If any man has done wrong, the harm is his own. But perhaps he has not done wrong. (Long)9.42When thou art offended with any man's shameless conduct, immediately ask thyself, Is it possible, then, that shameless men should not be in the world? It is not…
CopyPassage