PERSON

Democritus

Δημόκριτος ὁ ἈβδηρίτηςDemocritus Abderitac. 460 – c. 370 BCE
In brief

founder (with Leucippus) of the atomist system; the "laughing philosopher"; for Marcus the bearer of the chief rival cosmology ("atoms" versus "providence")

§ IBiography

Democritus of Abdera was a natural philosopher, founder — together with his teacher Leucippus — of atomism. He came from a wealthy family and, by tradition, spent his inheritance on travels (Egypt, Babylon, Persia, perhaps India) in the pursuit of knowledge. An extraordinarily prolific author (Thrasyllus grouped his works into tetralogies, as he did Plato's), but almost all is lost — only fragments survive, chiefly ethical. He was nicknamed the "laughing philosopher" — in the later tradition he was set against the "weeping" Heraclitus.

The principal biographical source is Diogenes Laertius IX 34–49. There are competing versions of his death, and Rogovin's note to 03-03 names both: by Diogenes Laertius, Democritus died of extreme old age (living, on some accounts, past a hundred); by Lucretius (De rer. nat. III 1039–1041), he ended his own life on sensing the approach of senile decay. Marcus gives a folk, deflating version: he was "eaten away by lice" (φθεῖρες).

§ IIPhilosophical significance

Atomism. Reality consists of an infinite multitude of indivisible bodies — atoms (ἄτομα, "uncuttable"), differing in shape, arrangement, and position — moving in the void (κενόν). The coming-to-be and passing-away of things is merely the combination and separation of atoms; qualities (colour, taste, heat) exist "by convention" (νόμῳ), while "in truth" (ἐτεῇ) there are only atoms and void. Worlds arise from atomic vortices without design or purpose — pure mechanical necessity, without providence.

Ethics. The goal of life is εὐθυμία (good cheer, "well-being of soul"), attained through measure and equanimity; a forerunner of Epicurean ἀταραξία and Stoic apatheia.

Why he matters for Marcus. Democritean (and the Epicurean that follows it) atomism is the chief rival cosmology to Stoic providence. Hence the recurring fork in Marcus: ἤτοι πρόνοια ἢ ἄτομοι — "either providence or atoms." Again and again Marcus sets the reader before this choice: the ordered, rational, providential cosmos of the Stoa — or the blind concourse of Democritus' atoms. Notably, Marcus does not always "close" the dilemma by force: at times he shows that even on the atomist hypothesis the Stoic ethical conclusion (accept what happens, hold fast to your own reason) still stands. Thus for Marcus Democritus is not simply mistaken but a standing mental opponent, a test of the soundness of the Stoic position.

§ IIIMentions in Marcus

  • 03-03 — death "by lice" in the catalogue of famous deaths (beside Socrates, whom "other lice" — human ones — killed).
  • 04-24 — Marcus quotes and refines Democritus's εὐθυμία-maxim ("Ὀλίγα πρῆσσε…", DK 68 B3): not "do few things" but "do what is necessary and socially due."
  • 07-31 — a recasting of the "νόμῳἐτεῇ" thesis (DK 68 B9/B117): "all by convention, in reality only the elements." Democritus goes unnamed (ἐκεῖνος, "that man"; Rogovin — "the poet"), but the fragment is recognizable; Marcus turns the atomist's reduction into a prop of indifference.
  • The fork "providence or atoms" (πρόνοια ἢ ἄτομοι) — Med. 4.3; 06-10; 07-32; 8.17; 9.28; 9.39; 10.6; 11.18; 12.14. Democritus is usually not named here, but it is his system that is the "atomist" horn of the dilemma.
PERSON

Democritus

Democritus AbderitaΔημόκριτος ὁ Ἀβδηρίτης
c. 460 – c. 370 BCE
In brief

founder (with Leucippus) of the atomist system; the "laughing philosopher"; for Marcus the bearer of the chief rival cosmology ("atoms" versus "providence")

Appears in6
Related0
Sections3

§ IBiography

Democritus of Abdera was a natural philosopher, founder — together with his teacher Leucippus — of atomism. He came from a wealthy family and, by tradition, spent his inheritance on travels (Egypt, Babylon, Persia, perhaps India) in the pursuit of knowledge. An extraordinarily prolific author (Thrasyllus grouped his works into tetralogies, as he did Plato's), but almost all is lost — only fragments survive, chiefly ethical. He was nicknamed the "laughing philosopher" — in the later tradition he was set against the "weeping" Heraclitus.

The principal biographical source is Diogenes Laertius IX 34–49. There are competing versions of his death, and Rogovin's note to 03-03 names both: by Diogenes Laertius, Democritus died of extreme old age (living, on some accounts, past a hundred); by Lucretius (De rer. nat. III 1039–1041), he ended his own life on sensing the approach of senile decay. Marcus gives a folk, deflating version: he was "eaten away by lice" (φθεῖρες).

§ IIPhilosophical significance

Atomism. Reality consists of an infinite multitude of indivisible bodies — atoms (ἄτομα, "uncuttable"), differing in shape, arrangement, and position — moving in the void (κενόν). The coming-to-be and passing-away of things is merely the combination and separation of atoms; qualities (colour, taste, heat) exist "by convention" (νόμῳ), while "in truth" (ἐτεῇ) there are only atoms and void. Worlds arise from atomic vortices without design or purpose — pure mechanical necessity, without providence.

Ethics. The goal of life is εὐθυμία (good cheer, "well-being of soul"), attained through measure and equanimity; a forerunner of Epicurean ἀταραξία and Stoic apatheia.

Why he matters for Marcus. Democritean (and the Epicurean that follows it) atomism is the chief rival cosmology to Stoic providence. Hence the recurring fork in Marcus: ἤτοι πρόνοια ἢ ἄτομοι — "either providence or atoms." Again and again Marcus sets the reader before this choice: the ordered, rational, providential cosmos of the Stoa — or the blind concourse of Democritus' atoms. Notably, Marcus does not always "close" the dilemma by force: at times he shows that even on the atomist hypothesis the Stoic ethical conclusion (accept what happens, hold fast to your own reason) still stands. Thus for Marcus Democritus is not simply mistaken but a standing mental opponent, a test of the soundness of the Stoic position.

§ IIIMentions in Marcus

  • 03-03 — death "by lice" in the catalogue of famous deaths (beside Socrates, whom "other lice" — human ones — killed).
  • 04-24 — Marcus quotes and refines Democritus's εὐθυμία-maxim ("Ὀλίγα πρῆσσε…", DK 68 B3): not "do few things" but "do what is necessary and socially due."
  • 07-31 — a recasting of the "νόμῳἐτεῇ" thesis (DK 68 B9/B117): "all by convention, in reality only the elements." Democritus goes unnamed (ἐκεῖνος, "that man"; Rogovin — "the poet"), but the fragment is recognizable; Marcus turns the atomist's reduction into a prop of indifference.
  • The fork "providence or atoms" (πρόνοια ἢ ἄτομοι) — Med. 4.3; 06-10; 07-32; 8.17; 9.28; 9.39; 10.6; 11.18; 12.14. Democritus is usually not named here, but it is his system that is the "atomist" horn of the dilemma.
Appears in6
3.3Hippocrates after curing many diseases himself fell sick and died​. The Chaldaei​ foretold the deaths of many, and then fate caught them too. Alexander, and Pom…3.5Labour not unwillingly, nor without regard to the common interest, nor without due consideration, nor with distraction; nor let studied ornament set off thy tho…3.10Throwing away then all things, hold to these only which are few; and besides bear in mind that every man lives only this present time, which is an indivisible p…4.24Occupy thyself with few things, says the philosopher, if thou wouldst be tranquil. But consider if it would not be better to say, Do what is necessary, and what…4.27Either it is a well-arranged universe or a chaos huddled together, but still a universe. But can a certain order subsist in thee, and disorder in the All? And t…7.31Adorn thyself with simplicity and modesty, and with indifference towards the things which lie between virtue and vice. Love mankind. Follow God. The poet says t…
CopyPassage