DOGMA

Gratitude to the gods — the natural response to the order of the cosmos

§ IFormulation

Since the cosmos is ordered by rational TERMprovidence, and everything that happens serves the good of the whole, the only rational attitude to one's own existence is gratitude. This is not politeness or bargaining (as in popular religiosity — "I give thanks in order to get more"), but the acknowledgement of a fact: I have received my being, my reason, and all the circumstances of my life. A complaint about what one has received has no ground; gratitude is not an affect but a correct categorisation. In Marcus, gratitude is tightly bound to acceptance of fate: the two are two modes of the single "yes" to what happens.

§ IISources in tradition

Cleanthes' Hymn to Zeus (SVF I 537) is the programmatic text of the Stoic attitude of gratitude. Epict. Disc. 1.16 (the whole of it "on providence" — "what else should I do but sing a hymn to god?"); Ench. 31; Disc. 1.6.19–22 ("if I were a nightingale, I would do what a nightingale does; I am rational — therefore I sing a hymn to god"). Sen. De ben. IV (the whole, on gratitude as a virtue). In Marcus: Med. 1 (the whole first book is an unfolded litany of thanks); 2.3; 5.31; 6.44; 9.40; 12.11.

§ IIINotes

In 02-03 this doctrine is the culmination: a life lived in the right teachings ends ἵλεως ἀληθῶς καὶ ἀπὸ καρδίας εὐχάριστος τοῖς θεοῖς — "truly serene and from the heart grateful to the gods" (see grateful-departure). Structurally, gratitude here functions as a criterion: that a person dies in gratitude is the sign that his philosophy is working. The alternative — γογγύζων ἀποθάνῃς, "to die murmuring" — is the diagnostic symptom that the teachings have not been interiorised.

DOGMA

Gratitude to the gods — the natural response to the order of the cosmos

Appears in 2
Related 3
Sections 3

§ I Formulation

Since the cosmos is ordered by rational TERMprovidence, and everything that happens serves the good of the whole, the only rational attitude to one's own existence is gratitude. This is not politeness or bargaining (as in popular religiosity — "I give thanks in order to get more"), but the acknowledgement of a fact: I have received my being, my reason, and all the circumstances of my life. A complaint about what one has received has no ground; gratitude is not an affect but a correct categorisation. In Marcus, gratitude is tightly bound to acceptance of fate: the two are two modes of the single "yes" to what happens.

§ II Sources in tradition

Cleanthes' Hymn to Zeus (SVF I 537) is the programmatic text of the Stoic attitude of gratitude. Epict. Disc. 1.16 (the whole of it "on providence" — "what else should I do but sing a hymn to god?"); Ench. 31; Disc. 1.6.19–22 ("if I were a nightingale, I would do what a nightingale does; I am rational — therefore I sing a hymn to god"). Sen. De ben. IV (the whole, on gratitude as a virtue). In Marcus: Med. 1 (the whole first book is an unfolded litany of thanks); 2.3; 5.31; 6.44; 9.40; 12.11.

§ III Notes

In 02-03 this doctrine is the culmination: a life lived in the right teachings ends ἵλεως ἀληθῶς καὶ ἀπὸ καρδίας εὐχάριστος τοῖς θεοῖς — "truly serene and from the heart grateful to the gods" (see grateful-departure). Structurally, gratitude here functions as a criterion: that a person dies in gratitude is the sign that his philosophy is working. The alternative — γογγύζων ἀποθάνῃς, "to die murmuring" — is the diagnostic symptom that the teachings have not been interiorised.

Related 3
Appears in 2
1.3 From my mother​, piety and beneficence, and abstinence, not only from evil deeds, but even from evil thoughts; and further, simplicity in my way of living, far … 2.3 All that is from the gods is full of Providence. That which is from fortune is not separated from nature or without an interweaving and involution with the thin…
Copy Passage