MOTIF

A little soul carrying a corpse

§ IImage

A saying of Epictetus cited by Marcus: ψυχάριον εἶ βαστάζον νεκρόν — "you are a little soul carrying a corpse." The human being appears as a soul lugging dead matter about. The image works in two directions at once: (1) it devalues the body, calling it not a "companion" or a "house" but a corpse — that in which there is no longer any life and nothing to prize; (2) it locates the "I": you are the ψυχάριον (the soul), not the νεκρόν (the body), which is merely carried. The body is not you; it is a weight attached to you (DOGMAthe self is in the soul / ruling faculty, not in the flesh).

The diminutive is deliberate: ψυχ-άριον (a poor little soul) set against the bare νεκρόν (corpse) — a disdain for both as small beside what matters: the rational ruling centre, which alone is the "man."

§ IISource

04-41 — the saying in pure form, attributed to Epictetus (preserved only here). The cognate series "I am the inner thing, not the vessel":

  • Med. 10.38 — what pulls the strings, hidden within, is the man; do not include the "vessel" and the attached organs;
  • 02-02 — the bare definition of the human composition (flesh, pneuma, ruling part);
  • Med. 8.24; 9.36 — the body in its material unsightliness;
  • 09-03 — the same diminutive pair: the ψυχάριον falls out of its ἔλυτρον ("husk") — a deflation of the pathos of death;
  • 09-24 — «πνευμάτια νεκροὺς βαστάζοντα»: the same image in the plural — people as little souls carrying corpses (the view from above on the Nekyia).

§ IIIUsage

In 04-41 the image serves the discipline of assent: the right view of oneself is a bare definition of the human being (soul + corpse) that strips the body of its inflated value. Logically it is paired with the "vessel" of Med. 10.38 and the definitions of the body (02-02): all of them separate the "I" from the flesh. A secondary effect is detachment (DOGMAself-is-hegemonikon) and an incidental memento mori (what you carry is already dead).

MOTIF

A little soul carrying a corpse

Appears in4
Related2
Sections3

§ IImage

A saying of Epictetus cited by Marcus: ψυχάριον εἶ βαστάζον νεκρόν — "you are a little soul carrying a corpse." The human being appears as a soul lugging dead matter about. The image works in two directions at once: (1) it devalues the body, calling it not a "companion" or a "house" but a corpse — that in which there is no longer any life and nothing to prize; (2) it locates the "I": you are the ψυχάριον (the soul), not the νεκρόν (the body), which is merely carried. The body is not you; it is a weight attached to you (DOGMAthe self is in the soul / ruling faculty, not in the flesh).

The diminutive is deliberate: ψυχ-άριον (a poor little soul) set against the bare νεκρόν (corpse) — a disdain for both as small beside what matters: the rational ruling centre, which alone is the "man."

§ IISource

04-41 — the saying in pure form, attributed to Epictetus (preserved only here). The cognate series "I am the inner thing, not the vessel":

  • Med. 10.38 — what pulls the strings, hidden within, is the man; do not include the "vessel" and the attached organs;
  • 02-02 — the bare definition of the human composition (flesh, pneuma, ruling part);
  • Med. 8.24; 9.36 — the body in its material unsightliness;
  • 09-03 — the same diminutive pair: the ψυχάριον falls out of its ἔλυτρον ("husk") — a deflation of the pathos of death;
  • 09-24 — «πνευμάτια νεκροὺς βαστάζοντα»: the same image in the plural — people as little souls carrying corpses (the view from above on the Nekyia).

§ IIIUsage

In 04-41 the image serves the discipline of assent: the right view of oneself is a bare definition of the human being (soul + corpse) that strips the body of its inflated value. Logically it is paired with the "vessel" of Med. 10.38 and the definitions of the body (02-02): all of them separate the "I" from the flesh. A secondary effect is detachment (DOGMAself-is-hegemonikon) and an incidental memento mori (what you carry is already dead).

Related2
Appears in4
4.41Thou art a little soul bearing about a corpse, as Epictetus used to say. (Long)8.27There are three relations between thee and other things: the one to the body which surrounds thee; the second to the divine cause from which all things come to …9.3Do not despise death, but be well content with it, since this too is one of those things which nature wills. For such as it is to be young and to grow old, and …9.24Quarrels of little children and their sports, and «poor spirits carrying about dead bodies», such is everything; and so what is exhibited in the representation …
CopyPassage