DOGMA

The true self is the ruling part

§ IFormulation

Out of all the constituents of the human composition — body, breath, sensations, emotions, relationships, name, reputation — only the TERMruling part is properly the "I." The body and the pneuma are borrowed from common matter and returned to it; everything else lies outside "what is up to us" (dichotomy-of-control). Genuine self-identification is with the rational part of the soul, the part capable of forming judgments and granting assent. In Epictetus this is TERMprohairesis ("the choosing will"); in Marcus the same thing is called ἡγεμονικόν, νοῦς, δαίμων.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF II 836 (the doctrine of the ἡγεμονικόν as the locus of personhood); III 169 (ὁρμή as a function of the ruling part); Epict. Disc. 1.1.7, 4.5.12 ("you are not flesh, not hair, but prohairesis"); Ench. 1; Disc. 2.5.4–5 ("my lot is to use impressions"). In Marcus: Med. 2.2; 3.6; 4.41 (with the Epictetan "you are a little soul carrying a corpse"); 05-10; 05-21 (honour the mightiest in the cosmos — and what is akin to it in yourself); 05-26; 05-27; 06-16; 6.32; 7.16; 07-55 (the νοερὰ κίνησις "circumscribes itself," means to hold first place over sense and appetite); 07-59 (ἔνδον ἡ πηγὴ τοῦ ἀγαθοῦ — the good is in the ruling part itself, one need only dig); 07-67 (περιορίζειν ἑαυτόν — to circumscribe yourself and keep your own in your power); 07-72 (the rational-social faculty judges below itself all that is neither rational nor social); 08-03 (the philosophers' ruling faculties are the same as themselves — τὰ ἡγεμονικὰ ἦν αὐτῶν ταὐτά); 08-16 (a change of mind is σὴ ἐνέργεια, the ruling part's own act); 08-27 (the body is only the enveloping ἀγγεῖον, a "vessel," not the "I"); 08-28 (no evil ascends into the ruling part from without); 08-40 (τίς αὐτός; — ὁ λόγος: the "self" is reason); 08-43 (joy is ὑγιὲς τὸ ἡγεμονικόν, the health of the ruling part); 08-48 (the ruling part, coiled into itself, is an unassailable citadel); 08-51 (the διάνοια stays pure under abuse — like an undefilable spring); 08-56 (each ἡγεμονικόν is a sovereign, holding τὴν ἰδίαν κυρίαν; another's vice does not enter it); 09-07 (ἐφ’ ἑαυτῷ ἔχειν τὸ ἡγεμονικόν — to keep the ruling part in its own power); 09-15 (things "outside the doors" are mute — τὸ ἡγεμονικόν pronounces about them; the "self" is the judging part); 09-26 (contentment with the ἡγεμονικόν doing its own work — "and enough"); 10.38; 12.3 (one of the clearest versions of the tripartite division). The Platonic precursor: Alcibiades I 130c ("the human being is the soul" — and specifically its rational part).

§ IIINotes

In 02-02 the doctrine unfolds as a three-step analysis: σαρκία, πνευμάτιον — external material; ἡγεμονικόν — what remains as the "I." The therapeutic move: what a person takes for himself (body, emotions, reputation) is in fact not him; conversely, what he often ignores (the rational instance) is in fact him. In Hadot this is a central moment of the "discipline of assent": correctly qualifying one's own boundaries. See also meditatio-mortis — the practice that draws the same boundary under the sign of finitude — and definitio — the practice that draws it under the sign of physical stripping-down.

In 03-03 the doctrine is compressed into a lapidary four-word formula: τὸ μὲν γὰρ νοῦς καὶ δαίμων, τὸ δὲ γῆ καὶ λύθρος — "the one is TERMmind and daimon, the other earth and gore." The body as the ἀγγεῖον (vessel) which the "I" mistakenly serves; death merely lifts that servitude. One of the most concentrated statements of the doctrine in the whole corpus.

In 03-05 the doctrine appears as self-sufficiency: ὀρθὸν εἶναι χρή, οὐχὶ ὀρθούμενον — "one must be upright, not set upright"; and "the god in you" (ὁ ἐν σοὶ θεός) is one's own guardian, needing neither oath nor witness nor the calm that others provide. The self is load-bearing, not propped from outside.

DOGMA

The true self is the ruling part

Appears in39
Related3
Sections3

§ IFormulation

Out of all the constituents of the human composition — body, breath, sensations, emotions, relationships, name, reputation — only the TERMruling part is properly the "I." The body and the pneuma are borrowed from common matter and returned to it; everything else lies outside "what is up to us" (dichotomy-of-control). Genuine self-identification is with the rational part of the soul, the part capable of forming judgments and granting assent. In Epictetus this is TERMprohairesis ("the choosing will"); in Marcus the same thing is called ἡγεμονικόν, νοῦς, δαίμων.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF II 836 (the doctrine of the ἡγεμονικόν as the locus of personhood); III 169 (ὁρμή as a function of the ruling part); Epict. Disc. 1.1.7, 4.5.12 ("you are not flesh, not hair, but prohairesis"); Ench. 1; Disc. 2.5.4–5 ("my lot is to use impressions"). In Marcus: Med. 2.2; 3.6; 4.41 (with the Epictetan "you are a little soul carrying a corpse"); 05-10; 05-21 (honour the mightiest in the cosmos — and what is akin to it in yourself); 05-26; 05-27; 06-16; 6.32; 7.16; 07-55 (the νοερὰ κίνησις "circumscribes itself," means to hold first place over sense and appetite); 07-59 (ἔνδον ἡ πηγὴ τοῦ ἀγαθοῦ — the good is in the ruling part itself, one need only dig); 07-67 (περιορίζειν ἑαυτόν — to circumscribe yourself and keep your own in your power); 07-72 (the rational-social faculty judges below itself all that is neither rational nor social); 08-03 (the philosophers' ruling faculties are the same as themselves — τὰ ἡγεμονικὰ ἦν αὐτῶν ταὐτά); 08-16 (a change of mind is σὴ ἐνέργεια, the ruling part's own act); 08-27 (the body is only the enveloping ἀγγεῖον, a "vessel," not the "I"); 08-28 (no evil ascends into the ruling part from without); 08-40 (τίς αὐτός; — ὁ λόγος: the "self" is reason); 08-43 (joy is ὑγιὲς τὸ ἡγεμονικόν, the health of the ruling part); 08-48 (the ruling part, coiled into itself, is an unassailable citadel); 08-51 (the διάνοια stays pure under abuse — like an undefilable spring); 08-56 (each ἡγεμονικόν is a sovereign, holding τὴν ἰδίαν κυρίαν; another's vice does not enter it); 09-07 (ἐφ’ ἑαυτῷ ἔχειν τὸ ἡγεμονικόν — to keep the ruling part in its own power); 09-15 (things "outside the doors" are mute — τὸ ἡγεμονικόν pronounces about them; the "self" is the judging part); 09-26 (contentment with the ἡγεμονικόν doing its own work — "and enough"); 10.38; 12.3 (one of the clearest versions of the tripartite division). The Platonic precursor: Alcibiades I 130c ("the human being is the soul" — and specifically its rational part).

§ IIINotes

In 02-02 the doctrine unfolds as a three-step analysis: σαρκία, πνευμάτιον — external material; ἡγεμονικόν — what remains as the "I." The therapeutic move: what a person takes for himself (body, emotions, reputation) is in fact not him; conversely, what he often ignores (the rational instance) is in fact him. In Hadot this is a central moment of the "discipline of assent": correctly qualifying one's own boundaries. See also meditatio-mortis — the practice that draws the same boundary under the sign of finitude — and definitio — the practice that draws it under the sign of physical stripping-down.

In 03-03 the doctrine is compressed into a lapidary four-word formula: τὸ μὲν γὰρ νοῦς καὶ δαίμων, τὸ δὲ γῆ καὶ λύθρος — "the one is TERMmind and daimon, the other earth and gore." The body as the ἀγγεῖον (vessel) which the "I" mistakenly serves; death merely lifts that servitude. One of the most concentrated statements of the doctrine in the whole corpus.

In 03-05 the doctrine appears as self-sufficiency: ὀρθὸν εἶναι χρή, οὐχὶ ὀρθούμενον — "one must be upright, not set upright"; and "the god in you" (ὁ ἐν σοὶ θεός) is one's own guardian, needing neither oath nor witness nor the calm that others provide. The self is load-bearing, not propped from outside.

Related3
Appears in39
2.2Whatever this is that I am, it is a little flesh and breath, and the ruling part. Throw away thy books; no longer distract thyself: it is not allowed; but as if…2.4Remember how long thou hast been putting off these things, and how often thou hast received an opportunity from the gods, and yet dost not use it. Thou must now…2.5Every moment think steadily as a Roman and a man to do what thou hast in hand with perfect and simple dignity, and feeling of affection, and freedom, and justic…2.6Do wrong to thyself, do wrong to thyself, my soul; but thou wilt no longer have the opportunity of honouring thyself. Every man's life is sufficient.​ But thine…2.7Do the things external which fall upon thee distract thee? Give thyself time to learn something new and good, and cease to be whirled around. But then thou must…2.8Through not observing what is in the mind of another a man has seldom been seen to be unhappy; but those who do not observe the movements of their own minds mus…2.10Theophrastus, in his comparison of bad acts — such a comparison as one would make in accordance with the common notions of mankind — says, like a true philosoph…2.13Nothing is more wretched than a man who traverses everything in a round, and pries into the things beneath the earth, as the poet says,​ and seeks by conjecture…2.15Remember that all is opinion. For what was said by the Cynic Monimus is manifest: and manifest too is the use of what was said, if a man receives what may be go…2.16The soul of man does violence to itself, first of all, when it becomes an abscess and, as it were, a tumour on the universe, so far as it can. For to be vexed a…3.1We ought to consider not only that our life is daily wasting away and a smaller part of it is left, but another thing also must be taken into the account, that …3.3Hippocrates after curing many diseases himself fell sick and died​. The Chaldaei​ foretold the deaths of many, and then fate caught them too. Alexander, and Pom…3.5Labour not unwillingly, nor without regard to the common interest, nor without due consideration, nor with distraction; nor let studied ornament set off thy tho…3.6If thou findest in human life anything better than justice, truth, temperance, fortitude, and, in a word, anything better than thy own mind's self-satisfaction …3.7Never value anything as profitable to thyself which shall compel thee to break thy promise, to lose thy self-respect, to hate any man, to suspect, to curse, to …3.16Body, soul, intelligence: to the body belong sensations, to the soul appetites, to the intelligence principles. To receive the impressions of forms by means of …4.1That which rules within, when it is according to nature, is so affected with respect to the events which happen, that it always easily adapts itself to that whi…4.41Thou art a little soul bearing about a corpse, as Epictetus used to say. (Long)5.10Things are in such a kind of envelopment that they have seemed to philosophers, not a few nor those common philosophers, altogether unintelligible; nay even to …5.21Reverence that which is best in the Universe, and this is that which makes use of all things and directs all things. And in like manner also reverence that whic…5.26Let the part of thy soul which leads and governs be undisturbed by the movements in the flesh, whether of pleasure or of pain; and let it not unite with them, b…5.27Live with the gods. And he does live with the gods who constantly shows to them that his own soul is satisfied with that which is assigned to him, and that it d…6.16Neither is transpiration, as in plants, a thing to be valued, nor respiration, as in domesticated animals and wild beasts, nor the receiving of impressions by t…7.55Do not look around thee to discover other men's ruling principles, but look straight to this, to what nature leads thee, both the universal nature through the t…7.59Look within. Within is the fountain of good, and it will ever bubble up, if thou wilt ever dig. (Long)7.67Nature has not so mingled [the intelligence] with the composition of the body, as not to have allowed thee the power of circumscribing thyself and of bringing u…7.72Whatever the rational and political [social] faculty finds to be neither intelligent nor social, it properly judges to be inferior to itself. (Long)8.3Alexander and Gaius​ and Pompeius​, what are they in comparison with Diogenes and Heraclitus and Socrates? For they were acquainted with things, and their cause…8.16Remember that to change thy opinion and to follow him who corrects thy error is as consistent with freedom as it is to persist in thy error. For it is thy own, …8.27There are three relations between thee and other things: the one to the body which surrounds thee; the second to the divine cause from which all things come to …8.28Pain is either an evil to the body- then let the body say what it thinks of it- or to the soul; but it is in the power of the soul to maintain its own serenity …8.40If thou takest away thy opinion about that which appears to give thee pain, thou thyself standest in perfect security.—Who is this self?—The reason.—But I am no…8.43Different things delight different people. But it is my delight to keep the ruling faculty sound without turning away either from any man or from any of the thi…8.48Remember that the ruling faculty is invincible, when self-collected it is satisfied with itself, if it does nothing which it does not choose to do, even if it r…8.51Neither in thy actions be sluggish nor in thy conversation without method, nor wandering in thy thoughts, nor let there be in thy soul inward contention nor ext…8.56To my own free will the free will of my neighbour is just as indifferent as his poor breath and flesh. For though we are made especially for the sake of one ano…9.7Wipe out imagination: check desire: extinguish appetite: keep the ruling faculty in its own power. (Long)9.15Things stand outside of us, themselves by themselves, neither knowing aught of themselves, nor expressing any judgement. What is it, then, which does judge abou…9.26Thou hast endured infinite troubles through not being contented with thy ruling faculty, when it does the things which it is constituted by nature to do. But en…
CopyPassage