MOTIF

Everything that exists is the seed of what will come from it

§ IImage

The seed (σπέρμα) is, for Marcus, not only the grain cast into the earth or the seed in the womb: everything that exists is in a manner the seed of what will come from it (σπέρμαπᾶν τὸ ὃν τοῦ ἐξ αὐτοῦ ἐσομένου). This is a radical widening of the ordinary notion: to count only the literally sown as seed is "very vulgar" (λίαν ἰδιωτικόν). In truth the whole cosmos works seminally: every state carries the next within it, and TERMchange is not perishing but generation. What dies does not vanish — it becomes the matter and the beginning of something new.

The image adjoins the Stoic doctrine of the seminal reason (TERMλόγος σπερματικός): the cosmic reason holds the generative principles of all things, and at the world's renewal everything returns into these seminal λόγοι to be born again. "Everything is a seed" dissolves the fear of death on the side of generation: my dissolution is my becoming-seed.

§ IISource

Med. 4.36 — the image in pure form. The cognate series of "return into the generative principle and rebirth":

  • 04-14 — the return into the seminal reason (λόγος σπερματικός) of the Whole;
  • 04-21 — souls taken up into the seminal reason of the Whole (bodies transmuted to make room);
  • Med. 6.24 — Alexander and his groom received into the same seminal principles;
  • Med. 7.23 — nature moulds from one matter a horse, then a tree, then a man;
  • Med. 9.35 — loss is nothing but change, and Nature delights in it.
  • Med. 09-01 — providence "conceived the seminal reasons (λόγοι) of what was to be," marking off the generative powers: the seminal reason as the source of becoming;
  • Med. 09-10 — fruit-bearing as a universal law: man, god, and cosmos all "bear fruit in their season"; confining "fruit" to the vine is "nothing to the point."

§ IIIUsage

In 04-36 the image serves the contemplation of nature and the discipline of desire: seeing every thing as a seed, the practitioner is reconciled to change and death (death = becoming the seed of the new, nothing is lost — cf. TERMmetabole, DOGMAamor-fati). Logically it is the generative counterpart to the images of "return into the Whole" (04-14, 04-21): those stress the return into the elements and the reason of the world, this the answering productivity (every end is a beginning). A secondary move is the correction of a narrow judgement: "seed" is not only the literal kind, and whoever thinks otherwise is ἰδιωτικός (untaught).

MOTIF

Everything that exists is the seed of what will come from it

Appears in4
Related4
Sections3

§ IImage

The seed (σπέρμα) is, for Marcus, not only the grain cast into the earth or the seed in the womb: everything that exists is in a manner the seed of what will come from it (σπέρμαπᾶν τὸ ὃν τοῦ ἐξ αὐτοῦ ἐσομένου). This is a radical widening of the ordinary notion: to count only the literally sown as seed is "very vulgar" (λίαν ἰδιωτικόν). In truth the whole cosmos works seminally: every state carries the next within it, and TERMchange is not perishing but generation. What dies does not vanish — it becomes the matter and the beginning of something new.

The image adjoins the Stoic doctrine of the seminal reason (TERMλόγος σπερματικός): the cosmic reason holds the generative principles of all things, and at the world's renewal everything returns into these seminal λόγοι to be born again. "Everything is a seed" dissolves the fear of death on the side of generation: my dissolution is my becoming-seed.

§ IISource

Med. 4.36 — the image in pure form. The cognate series of "return into the generative principle and rebirth":

  • 04-14 — the return into the seminal reason (λόγος σπερματικός) of the Whole;
  • 04-21 — souls taken up into the seminal reason of the Whole (bodies transmuted to make room);
  • Med. 6.24 — Alexander and his groom received into the same seminal principles;
  • Med. 7.23 — nature moulds from one matter a horse, then a tree, then a man;
  • Med. 9.35 — loss is nothing but change, and Nature delights in it.
  • Med. 09-01 — providence "conceived the seminal reasons (λόγοι) of what was to be," marking off the generative powers: the seminal reason as the source of becoming;
  • Med. 09-10 — fruit-bearing as a universal law: man, god, and cosmos all "bear fruit in their season"; confining "fruit" to the vine is "nothing to the point."

§ IIIUsage

In 04-36 the image serves the contemplation of nature and the discipline of desire: seeing every thing as a seed, the practitioner is reconciled to change and death (death = becoming the seed of the new, nothing is lost — cf. TERMmetabole, DOGMAamor-fati). Logically it is the generative counterpart to the images of "return into the Whole" (04-14, 04-21): those stress the return into the elements and the reason of the world, this the answering productivity (every end is a beginning). A secondary move is the correction of a narrow judgement: "seed" is not only the literal kind, and whoever thinks otherwise is ἰδιωτικός (untaught).

Related4
Appears in4
4.36Observe constantly that all things take place by change, and accustom thyself to consider that the nature of the Universe loves nothing so much as to change the…8.50A cucumber is bitter.- Throw it away.- There are briars in the road.- Turn aside from them. This is enough. Do not add, And why were such things made in the wor…9.1He who acts unjustly acts impiously. For since the universal nature has made rational animals for the sake of one another to help one another according to their…9.10Both man and God and the universe produce fruit; at the proper seasons each produces it. But if usage has especially fixed these terms to the vine and like thin…
CopyPassage