PERSON

Plato

ΠλάτωνPlato428/427 — 348/347 BCE
In brief

founder of the Academy, pupil of Socrates; for Marcus — a source of quotations on the soul's scale, the post, and death

§ IBiography

Plato, son of Ariston, an Athenian; in youth a follower of Socrates, and after his execution (399 BCE) — travels (Megara, Egypt by tradition, three Sicilian ventures with their unhappy experiments at the Syracusan court) and the founding of the Academy (c. 387 BCE) — the Mediterranean's first enduring philosophical school, which lasted nine centuries until Justinian's edict (529 CE). The corpus of ~28 genuine dialogues survives complete — a unique case for an ancient philosopher. The chief biographical source is DL III; the Seventh Letter (of disputed authenticity) is a self-testimony about the Sicilian ventures.

§ IIPhilosophical significance

For the Stoics Plato is at once ancestor and opponent. Ancestor — through Socrates: the line "virtue is knowledge, vice is ignorance," the care of the soul, the image of the philosopher at his post (Phd. 62b) passed straight into the Stoa; the very tripartition of philosophy (logic—physics—ethics) is of Academic origin (Xenocrates). Opponent — in ontology: against the transcendent Forms the Stoics set the immanent corporeal Logos, and against the soul's immortality — its dissolution into the Whole.

Marcus's relation is practical, without school polemic: Plato is a supplier of exercises and formulae. His favourite Platonic motifs: the scale of the soul that embraces "all time and all being" (Resp. 486a — the core of the view from above); the soldier at his post who does not quit the line for fear of death (Apol. 28d); contempt for mere length of life (Gorg. 512d–e). Plato's political idealism, meanwhile, Marcus soberly cuts away: "do not hope for Plato's Republic" (9.29) — to the emperor the city of ideas is not a programme but a measure of modest expectations.

§ IIIMentions in Marcus

  • 07-35 — a verbatim excerpt of Resp. VI 486a: to the soul contemplating "all time and all being" human life seems nothing great — "then death, too, is not terrible." Opens Book VII's Plato series.
  • 07-44 — Apol. 28b: for a man of any worth the reckoning is not "life or death" but only "is what I do just."
  • 07-45 — Apol. 28d–29a: where a man has posted himself (or been posted by his commander), there he must stay amid danger, counting neither death nor anything else before disgrace.
  • 07-46 — Gorg. 512d–e: not to cling to length of life but leave that to god, trusting that "no one escapes his destiny," and to consider instead how best to live the span allotted.
  • 07-63 — "every soul is deprived of truth against its will" (φησίν): a thesis going back to Plato (~ Sophist 228c / the Socratic "no one errs willingly"); the ground of gentleness.
  • 07-48 — the "Platonic" dictum on viewing earthly things from a height (herds, armies, weddings, law-courts): not found in the extant dialogues — either a paraphrase or a lost source; in spirit — Resp. 486a plus Theaet. 173e–174a (the philosopher surveying all from above).
  • 09-29 — "do not hope for Plato's Republic": be content with the smallest step forward.
  • 10-23 — the quotation about the "fold upon the mountain" (Theaet. 174d–e): in the philosopher's eyes the great landowner is indistinguishable from a shepherd fencing a fold and milking "bleatings"; the argument against changing place.

§ IVLiterature

  • Diogenes Laertius III — biography and catalogue
  • The Platonic corpus — Resp. VI 486a; Apol. 28b–29a; Gorg. 512d–e; Phd. 62b; Theaet. 173c–176a
  • J. Annas, Platonic Ethics, Old and New, Ithaca 1999
  • P. Hadot, The Inner Citadel, Cambridge (MA) 1998 — on Book VII's Plato quotations and the "view from above"
  • A. S. L. Farquharson, The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, Oxford 1944 — commentary ad loc.
PERSON

Plato

PlatoΠλάτων
428/427 — 348/347 BCE
In brief

founder of the Academy, pupil of Socrates; for Marcus — a source of quotations on the soul's scale, the post, and death

Appears in8
Related0
Sections4

§ IBiography

Plato, son of Ariston, an Athenian; in youth a follower of Socrates, and after his execution (399 BCE) — travels (Megara, Egypt by tradition, three Sicilian ventures with their unhappy experiments at the Syracusan court) and the founding of the Academy (c. 387 BCE) — the Mediterranean's first enduring philosophical school, which lasted nine centuries until Justinian's edict (529 CE). The corpus of ~28 genuine dialogues survives complete — a unique case for an ancient philosopher. The chief biographical source is DL III; the Seventh Letter (of disputed authenticity) is a self-testimony about the Sicilian ventures.

§ IIPhilosophical significance

For the Stoics Plato is at once ancestor and opponent. Ancestor — through Socrates: the line "virtue is knowledge, vice is ignorance," the care of the soul, the image of the philosopher at his post (Phd. 62b) passed straight into the Stoa; the very tripartition of philosophy (logic—physics—ethics) is of Academic origin (Xenocrates). Opponent — in ontology: against the transcendent Forms the Stoics set the immanent corporeal Logos, and against the soul's immortality — its dissolution into the Whole.

Marcus's relation is practical, without school polemic: Plato is a supplier of exercises and formulae. His favourite Platonic motifs: the scale of the soul that embraces "all time and all being" (Resp. 486a — the core of the view from above); the soldier at his post who does not quit the line for fear of death (Apol. 28d); contempt for mere length of life (Gorg. 512d–e). Plato's political idealism, meanwhile, Marcus soberly cuts away: "do not hope for Plato's Republic" (9.29) — to the emperor the city of ideas is not a programme but a measure of modest expectations.

§ IIIMentions in Marcus

  • 07-35 — a verbatim excerpt of Resp. VI 486a: to the soul contemplating "all time and all being" human life seems nothing great — "then death, too, is not terrible." Opens Book VII's Plato series.
  • 07-44 — Apol. 28b: for a man of any worth the reckoning is not "life or death" but only "is what I do just."
  • 07-45 — Apol. 28d–29a: where a man has posted himself (or been posted by his commander), there he must stay amid danger, counting neither death nor anything else before disgrace.
  • 07-46 — Gorg. 512d–e: not to cling to length of life but leave that to god, trusting that "no one escapes his destiny," and to consider instead how best to live the span allotted.
  • 07-63 — "every soul is deprived of truth against its will" (φησίν): a thesis going back to Plato (~ Sophist 228c / the Socratic "no one errs willingly"); the ground of gentleness.
  • 07-48 — the "Platonic" dictum on viewing earthly things from a height (herds, armies, weddings, law-courts): not found in the extant dialogues — either a paraphrase or a lost source; in spirit — Resp. 486a plus Theaet. 173e–174a (the philosopher surveying all from above).
  • 09-29 — "do not hope for Plato's Republic": be content with the smallest step forward.
  • 10-23 — the quotation about the "fold upon the mountain" (Theaet. 174d–e): in the philosopher's eyes the great landowner is indistinguishable from a shepherd fencing a fold and milking "bleatings"; the argument against changing place.

§ IVLiterature

  • Diogenes Laertius III — biography and catalogue
  • The Platonic corpus — Resp. VI 486a; Apol. 28b–29a; Gorg. 512d–e; Phd. 62b; Theaet. 173c–176a
  • J. Annas, Platonic Ethics, Old and New, Ithaca 1999
  • P. Hadot, The Inner Citadel, Cambridge (MA) 1998 — on Book VII's Plato quotations and the "view from above"
  • A. S. L. Farquharson, The Meditations of the Emperor Marcus Antoninus, Oxford 1944 — commentary ad loc.
Appears in8
7.35From Plato: The man who has an elevated mind and takes a view of all time and of all substance, dost thou suppose it possible for him to think that human life i…7.44From Plato: But I would make this man a sufficient answer, which is this: Thou sayest not well, if thou thinkest that a man who is good for anything at all ough…7.45For thus it is, men of Athens, in truth: wherever a man has placed himself thinking it the best place for him, or has been placed by a commander, there in my op…7.46But, my good friend, reflect whether that which is noble and good is not something different from saving and being saved; for as to a man living such or such a …7.48This is a fine saying of Plato: That he who is discoursing about men should look also at earthly things as if he viewed them from some higher place; should look…7.63Every soul, the philosopher says, is involuntarily deprived of truth; consequently in the same way it is deprived of justice and temperance and benevolence and …9.29The universal cause is like a winter torrent: it carries everything along with it. But how worthless are all these poor people who are engaged in matters politi…10.23Let this always be plain to thee, that this piece of land is like any other; and that all things here are the same with things on top of a mountain, or on the s…
CopyPassage