MED. 12.13Discipline of assent
Commentary

One line and two verdicts. γελοῖος and ξένος — ridiculous, and a stranger. The second word matters more than the first and usually drops out in translation: astonishment is declared not an error of judgement but a mark of not being from here. That is how a visitor behaves, for whom the customs of the country are news; and Marcus says that a man astonished at the course of things is a visitor in his own world.

Where the measure comes from. The passage stands in direct connection with 12.1, where it is promised that a man living according to nature "will cease to be a ξένος in his own native land and to wonder at the daily as though it were unlooked for" (θαυμάζων ὡς ἀπροσδόκητα). 12.13 is that same phrase compressed to a single line and turned into a diagnosis. Cf. 4.29: a stranger twice over is he who knows neither what is in the cosmos nor what happens in it.

ὁτιοῦν. "Anything whatever" — an intensifier, and it closes the loophole: the subject is not great calamities but any event at all. The measure taken is not endurance but knowledge: a man who knows the nature of things has nothing to be astonished at, just as no one is astonished that a fig tree yields a fig (8.15, 4.6 — where the verb is ξενίζεσθαι, from the same root as ξένος: to be astonished, in Greek, is to take a thing for foreign).

The genre. No command and no argument — a nominal exclamation, like 12.7 and 12.10. Book XII increasingly reduces its entries to a single formula: the work is already done, and what remains is the tag by which it can be recovered. The governing discipline is assent, the sustaining one desire.

DisciplineDiscipline of assent
Record added2026-07-16
Statuspublished
Discipline of assent

Original · ancient Greek
Leopold · Teubner 1908
Related1
Commentary

One line and two verdicts. γελοῖος and ξένος — ridiculous, and a stranger. The second word matters more than the first and usually drops out in translation: astonishment is declared not an error of judgement but a mark of not being from here. That is how a visitor behaves, for whom the customs of the country are news; and Marcus says that a man astonished at the course of things is a visitor in his own world.

Where the measure comes from. The passage stands in direct connection with 12.1, where it is promised that a man living according to nature "will cease to be a ξένος in his own native land and to wonder at the daily as though it were unlooked for" (θαυμάζων ὡς ἀπροσδόκητα). 12.13 is that same phrase compressed to a single line and turned into a diagnosis. Cf. 4.29: a stranger twice over is he who knows neither what is in the cosmos nor what happens in it.

ὁτιοῦν. "Anything whatever" — an intensifier, and it closes the loophole: the subject is not great calamities but any event at all. The measure taken is not endurance but knowledge: a man who knows the nature of things has nothing to be astonished at, just as no one is astonished that a fig tree yields a fig (8.15, 4.6 — where the verb is ξενίζεσθαι, from the same root as ξένος: to be astonished, in Greek, is to take a thing for foreign).

The genre. No command and no argument — a nominal exclamation, like 12.7 and 12.10. Book XII increasingly reduces its entries to a single formula: the work is already done, and what remains is the tag by which it can be recovered. The governing discipline is assent, the sustaining one desire.

DisciplineDiscipline of assent
Record added2026-07-16
Statuspublished