MED. 10.29Discipline of assent
Commentary

Taking the fear apart. Twenty words, and the whole device lies in κατὰ μέρος, "piece by piece." The fear of death is usually presented whole and is therefore irrefutable; Marcus demands that it be broken up into its parts: death is dreadful because it will deprive me of — what exactly? And the asking is not general but ἐφ’ ἑκάστου ὧν ποιεῖς — "at each of the things you do," one at a time.

The same verb as at 10.18. ἐφιστάνων — "halting, dwelling upon": literally the device of 10.18, only turned not upon a thing but upon one's own occupation. There one halted over an object to see it dissolving; here over one's own business, to test whether it is worth the fear.

A question whose answer is not supplied. Marcus gives no answer — and that is how the device works. The answer must arise of itself in the running through: here I am hearing a complaint, here dictating a letter, here eating — and of each of these one has to say "no, not because of this." The fear is not refuted by an argument; it runs dry for want of an object (cf. 2.14 — a man loses only the life he is living; 9.3 — do not despise death but be content with it).

Why this is a discipline of assent. The work is done not on the event but on the judgement "death is dreadful": the judgement is broken into checkable parts, and not one of them survives the check. The governing discipline is assent, the sustaining one desire.

DisciplineDiscipline of assent
Record added2026-07-16
Statuspublished
Discipline of assent

Original · ancient Greek
Leopold · Teubner 1908
Related1
Commentary

Taking the fear apart. Twenty words, and the whole device lies in κατὰ μέρος, "piece by piece." The fear of death is usually presented whole and is therefore irrefutable; Marcus demands that it be broken up into its parts: death is dreadful because it will deprive me of — what exactly? And the asking is not general but ἐφ’ ἑκάστου ὧν ποιεῖς — "at each of the things you do," one at a time.

The same verb as at 10.18. ἐφιστάνων — "halting, dwelling upon": literally the device of 10.18, only turned not upon a thing but upon one's own occupation. There one halted over an object to see it dissolving; here over one's own business, to test whether it is worth the fear.

A question whose answer is not supplied. Marcus gives no answer — and that is how the device works. The answer must arise of itself in the running through: here I am hearing a complaint, here dictating a letter, here eating — and of each of these one has to say "no, not because of this." The fear is not refuted by an argument; it runs dry for want of an object (cf. 2.14 — a man loses only the life he is living; 9.3 — do not despise death but be content with it).

Why this is a discipline of assent. The work is done not on the event but on the judgement "death is dreadful": the judgement is broken into checkable parts, and not one of them survives the check. The governing discipline is assent, the sustaining one desire.

DisciplineDiscipline of assent
Record added2026-07-16
Statuspublished