DOGMA

Fame is empty — neither praise nor posthumous remembrance is a good

§ IFormulation

Fame (δόξα), honour (τιμή), and above all posthumous fame (ὑστεροφημία) are not a good but an indifferent — and moreover an "empty" (κενόν) one. A thing's value is not increased by praise nor diminished without it; still less does it make sense to order one's life around the opinion of the not-yet-born. The one thing worth effort is one's own act, not another's report of it.

Marcus braces the thesis with several converging arguments:

  1. The praisers are no better than the blamed. The chaser of posthumous fame does not see that the admirers to come will be "just such as" the tiresome people of now whom he cannot bear — and "they too are mortal" (08-44).
  2. The rememberers will die too. Fame rests on memory, and memory on mortals: those who remember will soon be gone; the "ever-remembered" (τὸ ἀείμνηστον) is "wholly empty" (ὅλον κενόν) (04-19, 04-33).
  3. Scale. In the cosmic frame the whole earth is a point, and fame is in a corner of it (08-21); the view from above annuls the claim.
  4. No use to the dead. Even eternal remembrance gives nothing to the one honoured: he does not feel it (08-37).

A fine point of school doctrine: for the orthodox Stoics "good repute" (εὐδοξία) is counted among the προηγμένα — the preferred indifferents (TERMadiaphora), what one naturally prefers. Marcus, however, systematically radicalises it to κενόν (empty), drawing it toward the dispreferred. This is his personal emphasis: not "fame is a secondary good" but "fame is nothing."

§ IISources in tradition

Stoic axiology: "good repute" among the προηγμένα — DL VII 106; Stob. Ecl. II 79–85 W; the critique of the craving for fame — Epictetus, Ench. 24; Disc. 3.24; 4.6; Seneca, Ep. 79.13–18 (fame is "the shadow of virtue," it follows her but is not the aim), Ep. 102 (on posthumous fame). LS 58 (value and the indifferents). The Platonic background of contempt for reputation — Apology, Crito 44c–48a (not the opinion of the many but of the one who knows). In Marcus the motif is among the most frequent:

  • 08-44 — posthumous fame (ὑστεροφημία): the admirers to come are no better than today's tiresome people, and mortal (the principal locus).
  • 04-19 — the fame-lover forgets that those who remember him will also soon die.
  • 07-06 — the same regress compressed: the much-hymned are given to oblivion, and those who hymned them are long dead.
  • 04-33 — the names of the great grow antiquated; "eternal remembrance" is ὅλον κενόν (wholly empty).
  • 08-21 — the whole earth is a point, and fame is in a corner of it; the smallness of the claim.
  • 07-34 — look at the very judges (whose approval you are chasing).
  • 08-53 — the worth of praise is measured by the praiser: why the approval of one who does not please himself and curses himself thrice an hour?
  • 09-18 — "go in, into their ruling parts": the judges you fear judge even their own affairs awry — the worth of their approval collapses.
  • 09-27 — under blame, "go to their poor souls": their opinion of you is not worth being "pulled about" (σπᾶσθαι) over.
  • 09-29 — act "without looking round to see if anyone will notice" (μὴ περιβλέπου εἴ τις εἴσεται): work not for the onlooker.
  • 09-30 — the view from above + through time: how many do not know your name, will soon forget it — "neither memory, nor fame, nor anything else is of account."
  • 09-34 — "strip their souls bare": what conceit (ὅση οἴησις) — to think they harm by blame or help by praise.
  • 07-21 — near too is your forgetting of everything, and everything's forgetting of you.
  • 02-17 — posthumous fame is oblivion.
  • 06-18 — the contradiction of the fame-lover: they crave the praise of a posterity they would not themselves have honoured.
  • 03-10 — the brevity of all remembrance; live only the present.
  • Beyond the formatted corpus — Med. 9.30 (the view from above on the swarming), 12.27, 12.36.

§ IIINotes

The doctrine is an ethical target served by several practices and doctrines, and it must not be conflated with them:

  • The view from above is the optical exercise that yields the conclusion of fame's smallness; the doctrine itself is the conclusion, not the device.
  • TERMτιμή is the term "honour/esteem" (the thing itself); the doctrine is the judgment on its value (empty).
  • The dichotomy of control is the axis of control: another's opinion is not up to me; here it is added that it is also worthless.
  • The memory of death supplies the key argument (the rememberers are mortal, memory is effaced), but aims at accepting one's own death, not at devaluing repute.

The therapeutic move: to strip fame of the status of a good — and so to draw the sting both from vanity (the chase) and from being wounded by blame (cf. 8.44; 4.20 — the emerald is no worse without praise). It is linked to the TERMindifference of externals and to the norm that "the good of the rational being lies in his own action" (06-51).

DOGMA

Fame is empty — neither praise nor posthumous remembrance is a good

Appears in16
Related3
Sections3

§ IFormulation

Fame (δόξα), honour (τιμή), and above all posthumous fame (ὑστεροφημία) are not a good but an indifferent — and moreover an "empty" (κενόν) one. A thing's value is not increased by praise nor diminished without it; still less does it make sense to order one's life around the opinion of the not-yet-born. The one thing worth effort is one's own act, not another's report of it.

Marcus braces the thesis with several converging arguments:

  1. The praisers are no better than the blamed. The chaser of posthumous fame does not see that the admirers to come will be "just such as" the tiresome people of now whom he cannot bear — and "they too are mortal" (08-44).
  2. The rememberers will die too. Fame rests on memory, and memory on mortals: those who remember will soon be gone; the "ever-remembered" (τὸ ἀείμνηστον) is "wholly empty" (ὅλον κενόν) (04-19, 04-33).
  3. Scale. In the cosmic frame the whole earth is a point, and fame is in a corner of it (08-21); the view from above annuls the claim.
  4. No use to the dead. Even eternal remembrance gives nothing to the one honoured: he does not feel it (08-37).

A fine point of school doctrine: for the orthodox Stoics "good repute" (εὐδοξία) is counted among the προηγμένα — the preferred indifferents (TERMadiaphora), what one naturally prefers. Marcus, however, systematically radicalises it to κενόν (empty), drawing it toward the dispreferred. This is his personal emphasis: not "fame is a secondary good" but "fame is nothing."

§ IISources in tradition

Stoic axiology: "good repute" among the προηγμένα — DL VII 106; Stob. Ecl. II 79–85 W; the critique of the craving for fame — Epictetus, Ench. 24; Disc. 3.24; 4.6; Seneca, Ep. 79.13–18 (fame is "the shadow of virtue," it follows her but is not the aim), Ep. 102 (on posthumous fame). LS 58 (value and the indifferents). The Platonic background of contempt for reputation — Apology, Crito 44c–48a (not the opinion of the many but of the one who knows). In Marcus the motif is among the most frequent:

  • 08-44 — posthumous fame (ὑστεροφημία): the admirers to come are no better than today's tiresome people, and mortal (the principal locus).
  • 04-19 — the fame-lover forgets that those who remember him will also soon die.
  • 07-06 — the same regress compressed: the much-hymned are given to oblivion, and those who hymned them are long dead.
  • 04-33 — the names of the great grow antiquated; "eternal remembrance" is ὅλον κενόν (wholly empty).
  • 08-21 — the whole earth is a point, and fame is in a corner of it; the smallness of the claim.
  • 07-34 — look at the very judges (whose approval you are chasing).
  • 08-53 — the worth of praise is measured by the praiser: why the approval of one who does not please himself and curses himself thrice an hour?
  • 09-18 — "go in, into their ruling parts": the judges you fear judge even their own affairs awry — the worth of their approval collapses.
  • 09-27 — under blame, "go to their poor souls": their opinion of you is not worth being "pulled about" (σπᾶσθαι) over.
  • 09-29 — act "without looking round to see if anyone will notice" (μὴ περιβλέπου εἴ τις εἴσεται): work not for the onlooker.
  • 09-30 — the view from above + through time: how many do not know your name, will soon forget it — "neither memory, nor fame, nor anything else is of account."
  • 09-34 — "strip their souls bare": what conceit (ὅση οἴησις) — to think they harm by blame or help by praise.
  • 07-21 — near too is your forgetting of everything, and everything's forgetting of you.
  • 02-17 — posthumous fame is oblivion.
  • 06-18 — the contradiction of the fame-lover: they crave the praise of a posterity they would not themselves have honoured.
  • 03-10 — the brevity of all remembrance; live only the present.
  • Beyond the formatted corpus — Med. 9.30 (the view from above on the swarming), 12.27, 12.36.

§ IIINotes

The doctrine is an ethical target served by several practices and doctrines, and it must not be conflated with them:

  • The view from above is the optical exercise that yields the conclusion of fame's smallness; the doctrine itself is the conclusion, not the device.
  • TERMτιμή is the term "honour/esteem" (the thing itself); the doctrine is the judgment on its value (empty).
  • The dichotomy of control is the axis of control: another's opinion is not up to me; here it is added that it is also worthless.
  • The memory of death supplies the key argument (the rememberers are mortal, memory is effaced), but aims at accepting one's own death, not at devaluing repute.

The therapeutic move: to strip fame of the status of a good — and so to draw the sting both from vanity (the chase) and from being wounded by blame (cf. 8.44; 4.20 — the emerald is no worse without praise). It is linked to the TERMindifference of externals and to the norm that "the good of the rational being lies in his own action" (06-51).

Related3
Appears in16
2.17Of human life the time is a point, and the substance is in a flux, and the perception dull, and the composition of the whole body subject to putrefaction, and t…3.10Throwing away then all things, hold to these only which are few; and besides bear in mind that every man lives only this present time, which is an indivisible p…4.19He who has a vehement desire for posthumous fame does not consider that every one of those who remember him will himself also die very soon; then again also the…4.33The words which were formerly familiar are now antiquated: so also the names of those who were famed of old, are now in a manner antiquated, Camillus, Caeso, Vo…6.18How strangely men act. They will not praise those who are living at the same time and living with themselves; but to be themselves praised by posterity, by thos…7.6How many after being celebrated by fame have been given up to oblivion; and how many who have celebrated the fame of others have long been dead. (Long)7.21Near is thy forgetfulness of all things; and near the forgetfulness of thee by all. (Long)7.34About fame: look at the minds [of those who seek fame], observe what they are, and what kind of things they avoid, and what kind of things they pursue. And cons…8.21Turn it (the body) inside out, and see what kind of thing it is; and when it has grown old, what kind of thing it becomes, and when it is diseased. Short-lived…8.44See that thou secure this present time to thyself: for those who rather pursue posthumous fame do not consider that the men of after time will be exactly such a…8.53Dost thou wish to be praised by a man who curses himself thrice every hour? Wouldst thou wish to please a man who does not please himself? Does a man please him…9.18Penetrate inwards into men's leading principles, and thou wilt see what judges thou art afraid of, and what kind of judges they are of themselves. (Long)9.27When another blames thee or hates thee, or when men say about thee anything injurious, approach their poor souls, penetrate within, and see what kind of men the…9.29The universal cause is like a winter torrent: it carries everything along with it. But how worthless are all these poor people who are engaged in matters politi…9.30Look down from above on the countless herds of men and their countless solemnities, and the infinitely varied voyagings in storms and calms, and the differences…9.34What are these men's leading principles, and about what kind of things are they busy, and for what kind of reasons do they love and honour? Imagine that thou se…
CopyPassage