DOGMA

Virtue is sufficient for happiness

§ IFormulation

Ἀρετὴ αὐτάρκης πρὸς εὐδαιμονίαν — "virtue is sufficient for happiness." One of the hardest and most characteristic Stoic theses: for a happy life (understood as TERMεὔρους βίος — the smooth flow of existence) one needs only virtue, and nothing besides. Health, wealth, reputation, children, country — all these are "indifferents" (ἀδιάφορα); their presence or absence does not alter the status of a life as one that has gone well. The thesis provokes the natural objection ("but the person deprived of health suffers!"), and the Stoic answer: suffering is the artefact of false assents (pathos), not an objective deficit. The sage on the rack is eudaimōn to exactly the same degree as the sage in a palace.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF I 187 (Zeno); III 49–67 (Chrysippus' extensive argumentation); the classical formulations: DL VII 127; Stob. Ecl. II 71, 99 W; Cic. De fin. III 27; Tusc. V (the whole — "De virtute ad beate vivendum satis," the principal treatise); Sen. Ep. 9 (on the self-sufficiency of the sage); LS 63. In Marcus the thesis is everywhere assumed, but especially explicit at Med. 1.16; 02-05 ("how few things are needed for the smooth-flowing life"); 04-32 (contentment with one's own task, not chasing vanities); 05-12 (the seeming goods of the many vs true virtue); 05-14 (reason is self-sufficient); 05-15 (only the human is a human's; the τέλος is self-sufficient); 05-34; 05-37 (happiness is good acts of the soul, not the lot that fell); 06-02 (cold or heat, blame or praise, even death — indifferent to "doing what is fitting"); 06-16 (value lies only in the internal; else neither freedom, self-sufficiency, nor ἀπάθεια); 06-30 (the one fruit of earthly life is a holy disposition and social acts); 06-34 (scoundrels too revel in pleasures — so pleasure is no good); 07-28 (the ruling part is sufficient to itself in acting justly — and therein is γαλήνη); 07-42 (a verse of Euripides: "the good is with me — and the just"); 07-44 (Plato, Apol. 28b: look only to the justice of the act, not to life or death); 07-45 (Plato, Apol. 28d: reckon nothing ahead of the shameful); 07-66 (Socrates' measure — content with justice and piety, not glory); 07-67 (in the very least lies εὐδαιμόνως βιῶσαι); 07-73 (you did good, another received it — to seek a "third thing" (fame, return) is folly); 08-01 (the good — only what makes one just, temperate, brave, free; all else is no good); 08-10 (pleasure is no good: the sage never repents a missed pleasure); 08-19 (a human is not "for pleasure" — the notion will not bear such a τέλος); 09-42 (the wage of a kindness is the act itself: the eye demands no recompense for seeing); 12.27.

§ IIINotes

In 02-05 the doctrine is given a closing rhetorical formulation: ὁρᾷς πῶς ὀλίγα ἐστίν, ὧν κρατήσας τις δύναται εὔρουν καὶ θεουδῆ βιῶσαι βίον — "see how few things one must master in order to live a smoothly-flowing, god-fearing life." "A few things" = the four virtues (σεμνότης, φιλοστοργία, ἐλευθερία, δικαιότης) + freedom from the passions + the absence of murmuring against fate (amor-fati). This narrow list is the "sufficient" for eudaimonia. Linked to dichotomy-of-control: only virtue is in "what is up to us," and only virtue is what is needed; a happy dependence on the external is therefore ruled out not as a sub-ideal, but as a category error.

In 03-06 the thesis is cast as a decision-procedure: "is there anything better (κρεῖττον) than justice, truth, temperance, courage, and the self-sufficiency of reason? If not — give place to nothing else." The external (pleasure, wealth, power, praise) is declared ἑτερογενές — "of another kind" than the good of reason, and to set it alongside is οὐ θέμις. The sharp addition: the external, once granted even a slight value-as-good, "suddenly takes command" (κατεκράτησεν ἄφνω) — which is why only an all-or-nothing stance is admissible.

In 03-08 the thesis is applied to the length of life: fate never catches the purified soul's life ἀσυντελῆ (unfinished), "as one would say of a tragic actor who left before playing out his part." A good life is whole at any moment, because completeness is a matter of virtue, not of span; the fear of "dying too soon" is dissolved. (Lifespan is an indifferent.)

DOGMA

Virtue is sufficient for happiness

Appears in49
Related3
Sections3

§ IFormulation

Ἀρετὴ αὐτάρκης πρὸς εὐδαιμονίαν — "virtue is sufficient for happiness." One of the hardest and most characteristic Stoic theses: for a happy life (understood as TERMεὔρους βίος — the smooth flow of existence) one needs only virtue, and nothing besides. Health, wealth, reputation, children, country — all these are "indifferents" (ἀδιάφορα); their presence or absence does not alter the status of a life as one that has gone well. The thesis provokes the natural objection ("but the person deprived of health suffers!"), and the Stoic answer: suffering is the artefact of false assents (pathos), not an objective deficit. The sage on the rack is eudaimōn to exactly the same degree as the sage in a palace.

§ IISources in tradition

SVF I 187 (Zeno); III 49–67 (Chrysippus' extensive argumentation); the classical formulations: DL VII 127; Stob. Ecl. II 71, 99 W; Cic. De fin. III 27; Tusc. V (the whole — "De virtute ad beate vivendum satis," the principal treatise); Sen. Ep. 9 (on the self-sufficiency of the sage); LS 63. In Marcus the thesis is everywhere assumed, but especially explicit at Med. 1.16; 02-05 ("how few things are needed for the smooth-flowing life"); 04-32 (contentment with one's own task, not chasing vanities); 05-12 (the seeming goods of the many vs true virtue); 05-14 (reason is self-sufficient); 05-15 (only the human is a human's; the τέλος is self-sufficient); 05-34; 05-37 (happiness is good acts of the soul, not the lot that fell); 06-02 (cold or heat, blame or praise, even death — indifferent to "doing what is fitting"); 06-16 (value lies only in the internal; else neither freedom, self-sufficiency, nor ἀπάθεια); 06-30 (the one fruit of earthly life is a holy disposition and social acts); 06-34 (scoundrels too revel in pleasures — so pleasure is no good); 07-28 (the ruling part is sufficient to itself in acting justly — and therein is γαλήνη); 07-42 (a verse of Euripides: "the good is with me — and the just"); 07-44 (Plato, Apol. 28b: look only to the justice of the act, not to life or death); 07-45 (Plato, Apol. 28d: reckon nothing ahead of the shameful); 07-66 (Socrates' measure — content with justice and piety, not glory); 07-67 (in the very least lies εὐδαιμόνως βιῶσαι); 07-73 (you did good, another received it — to seek a "third thing" (fame, return) is folly); 08-01 (the good — only what makes one just, temperate, brave, free; all else is no good); 08-10 (pleasure is no good: the sage never repents a missed pleasure); 08-19 (a human is not "for pleasure" — the notion will not bear such a τέλος); 09-42 (the wage of a kindness is the act itself: the eye demands no recompense for seeing); 12.27.

§ IIINotes

In 02-05 the doctrine is given a closing rhetorical formulation: ὁρᾷς πῶς ὀλίγα ἐστίν, ὧν κρατήσας τις δύναται εὔρουν καὶ θεουδῆ βιῶσαι βίον — "see how few things one must master in order to live a smoothly-flowing, god-fearing life." "A few things" = the four virtues (σεμνότης, φιλοστοργία, ἐλευθερία, δικαιότης) + freedom from the passions + the absence of murmuring against fate (amor-fati). This narrow list is the "sufficient" for eudaimonia. Linked to dichotomy-of-control: only virtue is in "what is up to us," and only virtue is what is needed; a happy dependence on the external is therefore ruled out not as a sub-ideal, but as a category error.

In 03-06 the thesis is cast as a decision-procedure: "is there anything better (κρεῖττον) than justice, truth, temperance, courage, and the self-sufficiency of reason? If not — give place to nothing else." The external (pleasure, wealth, power, praise) is declared ἑτερογενές — "of another kind" than the good of reason, and to set it alongside is οὐ θέμις. The sharp addition: the external, once granted even a slight value-as-good, "suddenly takes command" (κατεκράτησεν ἄφνω) — which is why only an all-or-nothing stance is admissible.

In 03-08 the thesis is applied to the length of life: fate never catches the purified soul's life ἀσυντελῆ (unfinished), "as one would say of a tragic actor who left before playing out his part." A good life is whole at any moment, because completeness is a matter of virtue, not of span; the fear of "dying too soon" is dissolved. (Lifespan is an indifferent.)

Related3
Appears in49
2.5Every moment think steadily as a Roman and a man to do what thou hast in hand with perfect and simple dignity, and feeling of affection, and freedom, and justic…2.6Do wrong to thyself, do wrong to thyself, my soul; but thou wilt no longer have the opportunity of honouring thyself. Every man's life is sufficient.​ But thine…2.7Do the things external which fall upon thee distract thee? Give thyself time to learn something new and good, and cease to be whirled around. But then thou must…2.9This thou must always bear in mind, what is the nature of the whole, and what is my nature, and how this is related to that, and what kind of a part it is of wh…2.10Theophrastus, in his comparison of bad acts — such a comparison as one would make in accordance with the common notions of mankind — says, like a true philosoph…2.11Since it is possible that thou mayest depart from life this very moment, regulate every act and thought accordingly. But to go away from among men, if there are…2.12How quickly all things disappear, in the universe the bodies themselves, but in time the remembrance of them; what is the nature of all sensible things, and par…3.6If thou findest in human life anything better than justice, truth, temperance, fortitude, and, in a word, anything better than thy own mind's self-satisfaction …3.7Never value anything as profitable to thyself which shall compel thee to break thy promise, to lose thy self-respect, to hate any man, to suspect, to curse, to …3.8In the mind of one who is chastened and purified thou wilt find no corrupt matter, nor impurity, nor any sore skinned over. Nor is his life incomplete when fate…3.12If thou workest at that which is before thee, following right reason seriously, vigorously, calmly, without allowing anything else to distract thee, but keeping…4.8That which does not make a man worse than he was, also does not make his life worse, nor does it harm him either from without or from within. (Long)4.10Consider that everything which happens, happens justly, and if thou observest carefully, thou wilt find it to be so. I do not say only with respect to the conti…4.12A man should always have these two rules in readiness; the one, to do only whatever the reason of the ruling and legislating faculty may suggest for the use of …4.13Hast thou reason? I have. Why then dost not thou use it? For if this does its own work, what else dost thou wish? (Long)4.15Many grains of frankincense on the same altar: one falls before, another falls after; but it makes no difference. (Long)4.17Do not act as if thou wert going to live ten thousand years. Death hangs over thee. While thou livest, while it is in thy power, be good. (Long)4.19He who has a vehement desire for posthumous fame does not consider that every one of those who remember him will himself also die very soon; then again also the…4.20Everything which is in any way beautiful is beautiful in itself, and terminates in itself, not having praise as part of itself. Neither worse then nor better is…4.29If he is a stranger to the universe who does not know what is in it, no less is he a stranger who does not know what is going on in it. He is a runaway, who fli…4.30The one is a philosopher without a tunic, and the other without a book: here is another half naked: Bread I have not, he says, and I abide by reason. And I do n…4.31Love the art, poor as it may be, which thou hast learned, and be content with it; and pass through the rest of life like one who has intrusted to the gods with …4.32Consider, for example, the times of Vespasian​. Thou wilt see all these things, people marrying, bringing up children, sick, dying, warring, feasting, trafficki…4.37Thou wilt soon die, and thou art not yet simple, not free from perturbations, nor without suspicion of being hurt by external things, nor kindly disposed toward…4.39What is evil to thee does not subsist in the ruling principle of another; nor yet in any turning and mutation of thy corporeal covering. Where is it then? It is…4.42It is no evil for things to undergo change, and no good for things to subsist in consequence of change. (Long)4.47If any god told thee that thou shalt die to-morrow, or certainly on the day after to-morrow, thou wouldst not care much whether it was on the third day or on th…4.49Be like the promontory against which the waves continually break, but it stands firm and tames the fury of the water around it. Unhappy am I because this has h…4.50It is a vulgar, but still a useful help towards contempt of death, to pass in review those who have tenaciously stuck to life. What more then have they gained t…5.12How the things which seem good to most men might be shown to be otherwise, a man may learn from this. If a man should conceive certain things as being really go…5.14Reason and the art of reasoning are powers sufficient for themselves and for their own works. They set out from their own principle, and make their way to the e…5.15None of these things ought to be called a man's, which do not belong to a man, as man. They are not required of a man, nor does man's nature promise them, nor a…5.34Thou canst pass thy life in an equable flow of happiness, if thou canst go by the right way, and think and act in the right way. These two things are common bot…5.37I was once a fortunate man, but I lost it, I know not how. But fortunate means that a man has assigned to himself a good fortune: and a good fortune is good dis…6.2Let it make no difference to thee whether thou art cold or warm, if thou art doing thy duty; and whether thou art drowsy or satisfied with sleep; and whether il…6.16Neither is transpiration, as in plants, a thing to be valued, nor respiration, as in domesticated animals and wild beasts, nor the receiving of impressions by t…6.30Take care that thou art not made into a Caesar, that thou art not dyed with this dye; for such things happen. Keep thyself then simple, good, pure, serious, fre…6.34How many pleasures have been enjoyed by robbers, patricides, tyrants. (Long)7.28Retire into thyself. The rational principle which rules has this nature, that it is content with itself when it does what is just, and so secures tranquillity. …7.42For the good is with me, and the just. (Long)7.44From Plato: But I would make this man a sufficient answer, which is this: Thou sayest not well, if thou thinkest that a man who is good for anything at all ough…7.45For thus it is, men of Athens, in truth: wherever a man has placed himself thinking it the best place for him, or has been placed by a commander, there in my op…7.66How do we know if Telauges​ was not superior in character to Socrates? For it is not enough that Socrates died a more noble death, and disputed more skilfully w…7.67Nature has not so mingled [the intelligence] with the composition of the body, as not to have allowed thee the power of circumscribing thyself and of bringing u…7.73When thou hast done a good act and another has received it, why dost thou still look for a third thing besides these, as fools do, either to have the reputation…8.1This reflection also tends to the removal of the desire of empty fame, that it is no longer in thy power to have lived the whole of thy life, or at least thy li…8.10Repentance is a kind of self-reproof for having neglected something useful; but that which is good must be something useful, and the perfect good man should loo…8.19Everything exists for some end, a horse, a vine. Why dost thou wonder? Even the sun will say, I am for some purpose, and the rest of the gods will say the same.…9.42When thou art offended with any man's shameless conduct, immediately ask thyself, Is it possible, then, that shameless men should not be in the world? It is not…
CopyPassage