Providence or atoms — and one upshot. The cosmos runs "the same, up and down, from age to age" (ἐγκύκλια). Then the signature disjunction: either the "mind of the Whole" TERMimpels (ὁρμᾷ) toward each thing (then accept its impulse, ἀποδέχου τὸ ὁρμητόν), or it moved once and the rest follows by consequence (κατ’ ἐπακολούθησιν), or simply atoms. The upshot does not depend on the horn: DOGMA"if a god — all is well; if at random (εἰκῇ) — then at least do not you be at random" (cf. 7.32; 8.17). The practical conclusion is the same under either cosmology — not to murmur, but to hold one's order.
The waves of change. The second move: EXERCISE"soon the earth will cover us all"; and the earth itself will TERMchange, and so on to infinity. Whoever ponders the "surging waves" (ἐπικυματώσεις) of transformations and their speed "will despise everything mortal" (καταφρονήσει). EXERCISEThe contemplation of the flux deflates both fear and vanity at once. The governing discipline is desire.